Gender and Inclusive Justice Case: Sapana Pradhan Malla vs. Government of Nepal & Others, (NKP) (2065), No. 8, P. 917, DN: 7997
Case: Certiorari and Mandamus
Plaintiff: Sapana Pradhan Malla
Defendant: Government of Nepal et.al.
Decision Number: 7997
This case is relating to gender discrimination, polygamy, domestic violence, and equality of spouses under marriage law.
Facts of the Case:
Sapana Pradhan Malla and other lawyers associated with the Forum for Women, Law and Development filed a public interest petition challenging Sections 9 and 9A of the Marriage Chapter of the Muluki Ain.
Section 9 allowed a husband to marry another woman if his wife suffered from certain conditions, including incurable illness, mental illness, infertility or disability, or lived separately after taking her share of property.
Section 9A required the wife’s consent in some cases but removed this requirement in cases of incurable mental illness or separate residence after taking property.
The petitioners argued that these provisions discriminated against women based on their health, disability and family circumstances. They also argued that the law could expose women to pressure, threats and domestic violence to obtain consent for another marriage.
They challenged the provisions under the Interim Constitution of Nepal, 2007, CEDAW, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other international human rights instruments.
Plaintiff’s Claims:
The petitioners argued that Sections 9 and 9A violated women’s rights to equality, dignity, liberty, family life and freedom from violence. They further argued that a woman’s illness or disability could not justify her husband’s second marriage and that seeking her consent could expose her to pressure and violence. They also asked the Court to strike down the discriminatory provisions and direct the Government to ensure gender equality in marriage laws.
Defendants’ Arguments:
The Government argued that Section 9 restricted polygamy to limited situations, while Section 9A protected women by requiring their consent in most cases.
It also argued that women could seek legal protection against force or violence and that striking down the provisions could create a legal gap. Legal reforms were already being considered.
Legal Questions:
- Whether Sections 9 and 9A discriminated against women?
- Whether a husband could marry another woman because of his wife’s illness, disability, infertility, or separate residence?
- Whether the consent requirement could expose women to pressure or domestic violence?
- Whether the provisions were consistent with the Interim Constitution and CEDAW?
Different Court Decisions:
Supreme Court Decision:
The Supreme Court examined the disputed provisions in light of gender equality, women’s dignity, freedom from violence, and Nepal’s international obligations under CEDAW.
The Court observed that most of the grounds in Section 9 related to the wife’s health or disability. A wife suffering from serious illness, mental illness, blindness, or physical disability usually needed greater care and support from her husband. Her condition should not automatically become an opportunity for the husband to marry another woman.
The Court also noted that Section 9A did not require the wife’s consent when she was incurably mentally ill or when she had taken her share of property and lived separately. These exceptions could expose vulnerable women to further harm.
The Court held that the possibility of pressure, threats, and domestic violence had to be taken seriously. A legal provision should not be used in a way that allows a husband to obtain consent through fear or force.
The Court did not immediately declare all of Sections 9 and 9A void. It considered that striking down the entire provisions could create a legal gap. The Court also considered the Government’s stated commitment to reform gender discriminatory laws.
Instead, the Court used its constitutional power to issue a directive order. It ordered the Government to amend Sections 9 and 9A so that they would be consistent with the Interim Constitution and CEDAW. The amended law had to remove discrimination between husbands and wives and prevent women from experiencing further violence or unequal treatment.
Principles Established:
1. Marriage and family laws must ensure equal rights and treatment for men and women.
2. Illness, disability or infertility cannot justify discrimination against women.
3. Marriage must be based on free consent, without pressure, threats or violence.
4. The State must remove discriminatory laws and practices in line with CEDAW and constitutional equality.






