Gender and Inclusive Justice Case: Laxmi Dhikta & Others vs. Government of Nepal, NKP (2067), P. 1551, DN: 8464

Case: Mandamus
Plaintiff: Laxmi Dhikta
Defendant: Government of Nepal, Office of the Prime Minister and Council of Ministers
Decision Number: 8464

 

The case is relating to the right to safe and accessible abortion, reproductive rights, and the State’s duty to provide legal abortion services.

 

Facts of the Case:
Lakshmi Devi Dhikta, a woman from Ajayameru, Dadeldhura, had already given birth to five children. She later became pregnant again but did not want to continue the pregnancy.

At that time, Nepalese law permitted abortion in certain circumstances and required the service to be provided through approved health workers and institutions. Lakshmi and her husband therefore went to Dadeldhura Hospital to obtain an abortion.

The hospital required her to pay Rs. 1,130 for the service. Lakshmi was unable to pay the amount because of her financial condition. As a result, she could not obtain the abortion and was compelled to continue the pregnancy and give birth to another child.

The case was brought before the Supreme Court as a public-interest petition concerning access to abortion services. The petition also raised concerns about the practical availability of abortion services in Nepal. At the time, safe abortion services were not equally available in all districts, particularly in rural areas. Women could also face difficulties in obtaining information about legal abortion, finding trained service providers, and paying the required fees.

The petition further concerned the need for proper regulation of abortion services, including service fees, confidentiality of women seeking abortion, availability of trained health workers and health facilities, and public awareness about the legal availability of abortion.


Plaintiff’s Claims:
The petitioners claimed that legalising abortion was not sufficient if women could not actually access safe and affordable services. They argued that the State had a duty to make abortion services accessible, affordable, confidential and properly regulated, particularly for poor and rural women. Lakshmi also sought compensation for the harm she suffered after being unable to obtain the abortion.


Defendants’ Arguments:
The Government argued that Nepalese law had already legalised abortion in specified circumstances and that procedures had been established for providing safe abortion services. It stated that trained health workers and approved institutions were providing the service and that free services were available to poor women in appropriate cases. The Government also maintained that patient confidentiality was protected and that making or changing laws was primarily the responsibility of the legislature.


Legal Issues:

  1. Whether access to safe abortion is part of women’s reproductive rights?
  2. Whether the State has a duty to make legally permitted abortion services accessible and affordable?
  3. Whether failure to provide affordable abortion services violates women’s constitutional rights?
  4. Whether the existing legal and institutional framework was sufficient to protect women’s reproductive rights?


Different Court Decisions:
Supreme Court:
A Joint Bench of the Supreme Court, comprising Justices Kalyan Shrestha and Rajendra Prasad Koirala, allowed the petition in important respects.

The Court recognised abortion as part of women’s reproductive rights, including the right to decide whether or not to continue a pregnancy. It held that the State must ensure safe, affordable, accessible and quality abortion services.

The Court directed the authorities to improve abortion services, set reasonable fees, protect women’s privacy and conduct public-awareness programmes. It also directed the Government to develop a separate and adequate legal framework on abortion.

However, the Court denied Lakshmi’s claim for compensation due to insufficient evidence to determine the amount of loss.


Principles Established:
1. Reproductive rights include the right to decide whether and when to have children, including whether to continue a pregnancy.
2. Abortion is a matter of reproductive health and women’s rights, not just criminal law.
3. The State must ensure safe, affordable and accessible abortion services.
4. Poverty should not prevent women from accessing legal abortion services.
5. Women seeking abortion have the right to privacy, proper information and quality healthcare.
6. Claims for compensation must be supported by sufficient evidence to determine the loss.