Gender and Inclusive Justice Case: Dil Bahadur Bishwakarma & Others vs. Cabinet Secretariat & Others, NKP (2062), No. 4, P. 498, DN: 7531
Case: Mandamus
Plaintiff: Dil Bahadur Bishwakarma et.al
Defendant: Cabinet Secretariat & Others
Decision Number: 7531
The case is relating to the Chhaupadi practice and the protection of women’s constitutional rights during menstruation.
Facts of the Case:
The Dalit NGO Federation (DNF), through its President Dil Bahadur Bishwakarma, filed a public interest writ petition against the Government of Nepal. The case concerned the Chhaupadi practice followed in parts of Nepal, especially in the far western districts.
Under this practice, women and girls were sent out of their homes during menstruation. They were made to stay in a separate hut or in a cattle shed called a Chhaupadi hut. They were treated as impure and kept away from family members.
The women were often not allowed to enter the house, kitchen, temple, or water sources. They could not use ordinary household items. They were sometimes given only stale bread with salt and chilli. They were denied nutritious food such as milk, curd, and ghee.
The huts were usually dirty, unsafe, and poorly ventilated. Women had to sleep on straw, sacks, or rough mats. They faced cold, illness, malnutrition, physical weakness, social humiliation, and mental suffering. Some women also faced sexual violence, snake bites, animal attacks, and even death while staying in the huts.
The petitioners argued that the practice was based on superstition and discrimination. It violated women’s right to equality, personal liberty, dignity, health, and life. They said that the Government had failed to take effective steps to stop the practice.
Plaintiff’s Claims:
The petitioners claimed that sending menstruating women to Chhaupadi huts was an inhuman and discriminatory practice. They argued that it treated women as inferior because of a natural biological process.
They asked the Court to order the Government to immediately stop the practice and to declare it a social evil. They also requested a law against discrimination during menstruation.
They asked for a study of the health effects of Chhaupadi on women and children. They also requested public awareness programmes, local level action, and guidelines to protect women until detailed legislation was made.
Defendants’ Arguments:
The Government authorities argued that Chhaupadi was a social and cultural problem that could be gradually removed through awareness, education, and empowerment. They stated that government agencies were already conducting programmes to reduce harmful social practices and discrimination.
Legal Questions:
- Whether Chhaupadi violated women’s constitutional rights?
- Whether forcing menstruating women to live in separate huts was discriminatory and inhuman?
- Whether the Government had taken sufficient measures to end Chhaupadi?
- Whether the Supreme Court could issue directions to the Government to protect women from the practice?
Different Court Decisions:
Supreme Court Decision:
Supreme Court recognised that Chhaupadi was still practised in the far western districts. Women were forced to stay in unsafe huts, denied nutritious food and restricted from using household facilities during menstruation.
The Court held that the Government had failed to take effective steps to end the practice. It stated that the State must protect women’s rights to life, health, dignity, equality and personal liberty.
The Court directed the Prime Minister’s Office to declare Chhaupadi a social evil within one month. It also ordered the Health Ministry to study its effects on women and children and the Local Development Ministry to conduct public awareness programmes.
The Ministry of Women, Children and Social Welfare was directed to prepare guidelines against menstrual discrimination within three months. The Government was also asked to study the need for specific laws to eliminate the practice.
Principles Established:
1. Chhaupadi is a harmful and discriminatory practice. Menstruation cannot be used to treat women as impure or inferior.
2. Chhaupadi can violate women’s rights to life, health, dignity, equality and personal liberty.
3. The State has a duty to protect women from harmful social practices. General awareness programmes alone are not enough without effective action.
4. Social and cultural traditions cannot justify violations of constitutional rights.
5. Public interest litigation allows courts to protect vulnerable groups and issue necessary directions when fundamental rights are threatened by harmful practices or government inaction.






