Gender and Inclusive Justice Case: Meera Dhungana vs. Council of Ministers & Others, NKP (2063), No. 8, P. 972, DN: 7743
Case: Voidance of the unconstitutional law
Plaintiff: Meera Dhungana
Defendant: Council of Ministers & Others
Decision Number: 7743
The case is relating to women’s equal property rights and the freedom to marry a person of their choice.
Facts:
Meera Dhungana, on behalf of the Forum for Women, Law and Development and in her own capacity, filed a constitutional petition before the Supreme Court. She challenged Section 7 of the Stri Ansh Dhan chapter of the Muluki Ain.
Section 7 provided that if a woman transferred property belonging to her, other than dowry or personal property, by any methods, and later married the same man who received the property, the earlier transaction would not be valid. The person who would otherwise have inherited the property could take it back.
The provision applied only when the transfer was made by a woman to a man and the woman later married that man. It did not apply in the same way when a man transferred his property to a woman and later married her.
The law therefore affected a woman’s right to deal freely with her own property. It also created a connection between the validity of a property transaction and the woman’s later decision to marry the person who received the property.
Plaintiff’s Claims:
The petitioner claimed that Section 7 discriminated against women and violated the constitutional right to equality. She argued that women should have the same right as men to use, sell, gift or otherwise transfer their own property.
She also argued that a woman should be free to marry a person of her choice without losing the legal effect of an earlier property transaction. She asked the Court to declare the discriminatory part of Section 7 unconstitutional and invalid.
Defendants’ Arguments:
The Government argued that the provision was based on Nepal’s traditional system of family property and inheritance. It said the rule was intended to prevent dishonest property transactions and protect family interests and social morality.
The respondents also argued that Parliament was responsible for making and changing laws. They pointed out that other discriminatory provisions had already been changed through legal reform and asked the Court to dismiss the petition.
Legal Questions:
- Whether Section 7 discriminated against women and violated the right to equality?
- Whether a woman had the same right as a man to freely transfer her own property?
- Whether a later marriage could invalidate an earlier lawful property transaction?
- Whether Section 7 unlawfully restricted a woman’s freedom to marry a person of her choice?
Different Court Decisions:
Supreme Court Decision:
The Supreme Court found that Section 7 discriminated against women. If a woman transferred her property to a man and later married him, the transaction could be cancelled and the property recovered by another heir. No similar restriction applied to men.
The Court held that women have equal ownership rights, including the right to use, sell, gift or transfer their property. These rights cannot be restricted simply because a woman later marries the recipient.
It further held that property rights and the freedom to marry are separate rights. A lawful property transaction cannot be invalidated merely because a woman chooses to marry the recipient.
Although the provision excluded dowry and personal property, the Court found no reasonable basis for imposing the restriction only on women.
Relying on constitutional guarantees of equality and equal protection, along with CEDAW, ICCPR and ICESCR, the Court declared the disputed provision of Section 7 unconstitutional, invalid and void from the date of the judgment.
Principles Established:
1. Women and men are entitled to equal protection of the law and equal rights to own and transfer property.
2. Ownership includes the right to use, sell, gift or otherwise transfer one’s property.
3. Marriage does not take away a woman’s property rights or invalidate an earlier lawful property transaction.
4. The right to property and the freedom to marry are separate rights.
5. A woman cannot be penalised for marrying a person of her choice.






